In Matters of Scientific Debate, Follow the Houdini Rule

在科学辩论中,遵循霍迪尼法则

Illustration of a science educator in front of a chalkboard with many notes and drawings

Illustration of a science educator in front of a chalkboard with many notes and drawings

2024-07-30  921  中等
字体大小

Mainstream media reported on these efforts, often uncritically. “Soul Has Weight, Physician Thinks,” declared a New York Times headline on March 11, 1907. With four medical colleagues as witnesses, “reputable physician” Duncan Mac­­Dougall of Massachusetts had placed the body of a dying man on a specially designed bed, with built-in scales, next to an empty but otherwise identical bed. At the moment of the man’s death, the scales reportedly shifted, indicating a weight loss on his side of approximately one ounce. Five other cases showed losses between an ounce and half an ounce. In the case of one large, “phlegmatic” man, the weight loss was delayed a minute; MacDougall concluded that the deceased’s sluggish nature led his soul to depart without alacrity. (Wikipedia suggests this experiment is the source of the popular notion that the human soul weighs 21 grams.)

请登录后继续阅读完整文章

还没有账号?立即注册

成为会员后您将享受无限制的阅读体验,并可使用更多功能,了解更多


免责声明:本文来自网络公开资料,仅供学习交流,其观点和倾向不代表本站立场。